Haiti floods: 847 homes destroyed as Dominican Republic reports 30 cut-off communities

Two governments count their damage differently. Sanad compared Haiti's provisional civil-protection figures with the neighbouring country's emergency update.

Sanad comparison graphic showing 847 destroyed, 219 damaged and 2,130 flooded homes in Haiti's provisional report.

Four people have died and two are missing after heavy rain in south-western Haiti, according to the country’s civil protection agency. The same weather system left at least 30 communities cut off in the Dominican Republic. These figures come from two national authorities using different measures; they should not be collapsed into a single island-wide damage total.

Haiti’s General Directorate of Civil Protection, cited in a 27 October Caribbean Media Corporation report, gave a provisional count of 3,209 families affected across 21 communes. It reported 847 homes destroyed, 219 damaged and 2,130 flooded in parts of the country.

Associated Press rounded the family figure to more than 3,200 and described hundreds of homes destroyed. Those two reports are compatible: the AP account repeats the official figures at a lower level of detail, rather than supplying an independent household survey.

Two countries, two sets of measurements

Indicator as reported 27 October Haiti Dominican Republic
Deaths 4, plus 2 missing Not specified in the cited update
Communities affected or cut off 21 communes affected At least 30 communities cut off
Housing damage 847 destroyed, 219 damaged, 2,130 flooded More than 100 homes flooded

Sources: Haiti’s Civil Protection Agency via CMC; Dominican Emergency Operations Center via AP. The categories and reporting jurisdictions differ.

A commune described as affected in Haiti is not necessarily the same as a community reported as cut off across the border. Likewise, houses flooded, damaged and destroyed are not interchangeable categories. They cannot be added together without knowing how the agency defines each count and whether homes appear in more than one category.

Haitian authorities said roads were blocked, farmland was damaged and communications were difficult in some districts. The rain was associated with a low-pressure system affecting the northern Caribbean. Officials were beginning to arrange temporary shelters, the CMC account said.

The number that most urgently needs updating is not a single grand total. It is how many families remain unable to reach shelter, safe water, food and medical help as road access changes.

How Sanad checked this: We compared the civil-protection figures published by CMC with AP’s report of both countries. We have no independent on-the-ground assessment, and these numbers remain provisional as of 27 October.

The sanad of this story

  1. Four killed as heavy rains batter Haiti, citing civil protection — Caribbean Media Corporation via CANA
  2. Haiti and Dominican Republic flooding, 27 October — Associated Press

Spotted an error? Request a correction. Read our editorial standards.

Related