Pakistan Science Club photo contest: judges and public chose six different winners
Sanad compared the two published award lists. None of the three judges' picks appeared among the three public-vote winners.
Six photographs, two voting tracks and no overlap among the announced winners: that is the most interesting detail in Pakistan Science Club’s October “Science on My Walk” competition.
The club published its results on 10 October 2026, listing three Judges’ Choice places and three People’s Choice places. Sanad placed the results side by side to show which photographers were selected through each route.
| Place | Judges’ Choice | People’s Choice |
|---|---|---|
| First | Amna Bibi — Nature Waterproof Jacket | Aliza Barkat — Niche Selection in Tropical Forest |
| Second | Rafi Ullah — Scarlet | Usman Ashfaq — Urban Constructed Waterway Ecosystem |
| Third | Rafay Mahmood — A Lantern’s Tale | Azeem Udin Arshad — Swat River Spring |
Every name and image title is from the club’s original results announcement.
What the lists tell us — and what they don’t
The two tracks produced six different names in their top threes. That is a direct comparison of published lists. It does not establish that the judges and public disagreed over the same photographs, because the club’s announcement does not provide a full list of entries, the scoring method or how many votes each received.
Likewise, titles such as Nature Waterproof Jacket and Niche Selection in Tropical Forest suggest scientific questions, but they do not by themselves prove a particular material property or ecological mechanism. Those would require examining each photograph and the maker’s explanation.
The project is useful for educators precisely because students can take an ordinary object and ask how it works. How does a surface repel water? What makes a forest species thrive in one habitat but not another? What evidence would help distinguish an attractive photograph from a scientific observation?
Pakistan Science Club also runs science education and maker activities. This contest puts the same habit of questioning into a public challenge that doesn’t require a laboratory.
How Sanad checked this: We compared the two prize lists in the club’s published 10 October announcement. We did not review the entries, interview photographers, independently count votes or verify the judging criteria.
The sanad of this story
- Science on My Walk – Meet the Winners! — Pakistan Science Club
- Pakistan Science Club photo hunt and programme information — Pakistan Science Club
Spotted an error? Request a correction. Read our editorial standards.
Related
Good News · Asia
Pakistan honours sisters for hospice care: what two reports establish about the awards
Mariam Gill and Genevieve Ram Lal were among the women recognised in Islamabad. The accounts describe different totals, which should not be treated as the same list.
Humanitarian · Asia
Myanmar: ASEAN aid mission targets 11,000 families — access is the test
A Philippines-led mission has a concrete distribution target. Sanad compared earlier promises with the new plan and found no confirmed delivery total yet.
Good News · Europe
East London Mosque's charity runs: £250,000 raised across two events, organisers say
Sanad checked the men's and women's race reports and fundraiser details, while acknowledging a participant's death during the event.
